NMEA awards, performance & reliability?

... written for Panbo by Ben Ellison and posted on Jan 18, 2008

Raymic_Hand

When I wrote about last year’s most innovative marine electronics a while back, I said I’d deal with the NMEA Awards separately. Well, here goes. But do understand that these awards are determined by mail-in votes from NMEA dealer and trade members and, while I don’t know for sure what the criteria are, I’d say that they’re more about performance and reliability than innovation. I’d guess there’s also a natural bias toward the sort of bigger gear that dealer/installers tend to work with, and probably also toward the brands that have particularly well developed dealer networks. “Best of Show” is a little different, however, as it’s voted on by everyone who attends the NMEA conference (mutts like me excepted).


Industry Awards
   Autopilot:  Raymarine ST8002 Plus
   Fish Finding:  Furuno FCV 585
   Radar:  Furuno FR8002 Series
   Communication:  ICOM America M604
   Entertainment:  KVH Tracvision M3ST
   Navigation:  Furuno MAX SEA Navnet Explorer v12.5
Marine Specialty Awards (any category but the above):
   First Place:  FLIR Navigator Thermal Imaging Camera
   Second Place:  Navionics Platinum Charts
Manufacturer of the Year Support Award: Furuno USA
Best of Show: Raymarine Ray 218 VHF/Hailer (Ray Mic above).
Technician of the Year: Robert J. McClure, McClure Marine Electronics
Lifetime Achievement Award: Steve Boucher, CEO/Chairman of Airmar Technology. (Not awarded since 2002, and very much deserved by Boucher, I think.)


Meanwhile, following up on my best new general tech entry, you might enjoy checking out the CES Innovation Awards. Among other neat gear of interest is the Sanyo Xacti waterproof video camera I spotted last summer; I got to try the HD but non-waterproof version of this baby last month, and liked it very much. Finally there’s David Pogue’s take on developments-in-waiting he spied out at CES. How about super thin, super high contrast, low power Sony OLED screens (stupid expensive now, but we know how that goes). Hell yes, we can something with those around a boat. 

Comments

Ben, if you like OLED, your wait may not be as long as you think. Furuno's FI-50 boat instruments (sort of announced, but definitely not shipping) have OLED displays.

Posted by: Russ at January 20, 2008 1:47 AM | Reply

The Raymarine 218 may be a great radio, but the remote mic is blown away by the ICOM Command Mic III which has a rotary jog dial to change chanels rather than those infuriating up down buttons. But, that is my opinion.

Posted by: melkal at January 21, 2008 1:51 PM | Reply

Best of show is a VHF radio? Pretty dull show.
But keep up the standards folks, you do that well.

Posted by: Sandy at January 22, 2008 11:30 AM | Reply

Leave a comment