NavPlanner 3.13, still needs work

... written for Panbo by Ben Ellison and posted on Jun 26, 2006

NavPlanner save © Panbo

Navionics kindly sent me soon-to-be-shipped version 3.13 of NavPlanner, but I’m afraid it’s not going to satisfy the critics (some of whom ganged up on this software rather fiercely at The Hull Truth). The screen shot above shows all the plotter file formats it supports, as well as some interesting bathy detail off Key West on a Fish’n’Chip. 3.13 does seem faster, and it handled every kind of chart card without crashing, and I was able to build, save, and open various route types without trouble. However it’s still pretty clunky software. For instance, there is no simple hand grab tool to position the chart just where you want it, and when you try to move off the visible chart while mousing a route it doesn’t even know to pan without getting additional commands. Also you can’t change the type of depth unit used (usually an advantage of vector charts) and most U.S. charts are thus shown in Meters.

I could go on, but suffice it to say RayTech 6.0 handles Navionics charts much better, especially Platinum ones. In fact, even, say, Northstar users might want to do their planning in RayTech and then just use NavPlanner to convert the routes to their format. That’s possible (I checked), but there may be other ways to make the transfer, especially as RayTech will export routes to coma delimited or Excel formats. And note that Fugawi is just about to add Navionics card support to its ENC software. (Both Raymarine and Fugawi will sell the special reader needed for about $75).

But if you are using NavPlanner, I can help you out with one annoying detail (that I’m told will be fixed in a future version). Right now NavPlanner (unlike most every other chart viewer out there) does not automatically, or even semi-automatically, register charts and then graphically show you what’s available. Instead you have to find the "Charts" folder and then pick your desired region from a coded list, like below. This is an extreme example as that’s a Silver card with the whole U.S. Coast on it, but even a regular XL3 card has 3 XL files on it. Which is where? Navionics doesn’t have an online code list but I found one at Boaters Land.

NavPlanner file open

Comments

I would like to see a moving map GPS that could display the NOAA ENC charts. Advantage besides cost; are frequent updates and most important they are official and "legal" for navigation.

I know none of the major manufactures are likely to touch this one, but I can wish.

Thanks Ben for keeping us informed!


Pat Harman

Posted by: Pat Harman at June 27, 2006 1:57 AM | Reply

Try this link..
ENCs on your Garmin GPS

Posted by: Douglas at June 27, 2006 7:29 AM | Reply

Very interesting, I don't have most of the software tools. But the demonstration in the link upabove shows it can be done.

I would pay for a utility that did this for my Garmin 2006c. Better yet I would purchase a GPS that worked with the NOAA ENC charts.

Pat Harman

Posted by: Pat Harman at June 27, 2006 9:47 PM | Reply

Pat,

I'm intrigued, but confused... What is it that attracts you to the NOAA ENC charts?

Is it that they are free of charge? Or do you believe them to be more accurate/up-to-date than the product you can purchase from Garmin/Navionics/C-Map?

What is the appeal from your perspective?

Posted by: Anonymous at June 28, 2006 8:04 PM | Reply

Maybe I can clear up some of your confusion. Presumably because the ENC charts are vector they would display better and faster on a GPS moving map display unit that could display them. Cost is certainly a factor, but NOAA charts are official (meaning no disclaimer). The NOAA charts will always be the latest available, so I can down load what I need at the start of every voyage.

There is plenty of opportunity for commercial cartographers to add value to the NOAA data.

Pat Harman

Posted by: Pat Harman at June 29, 2006 12:04 AM | Reply

Leave a comment